Menu
NTA HomepageHOME

Report on 2015 Public Consultation on Taxi Roof Signs

Public Consultation on Taxi Roof Signs 2015

 

Background

The National Transport Authority (Authority) is a State body set up under statute in 2009, responsible for the regulation of the small public service vehicle (SPSV) sector, i.e. taxis, wheelchair accessible taxis, hackneys, wheelchair accessible hackneys, local area hackneys and limousines, together with their drivers, owners and associated services. At 30 June 2015, a total of 21,209 SPSVs were licensed to the Irish fleet; 17,485 were taxis and wheelchair accessible taxis with c.60% of those in the Greater Dublin Area.

Taxi Regulation Review Report

In January 2012, the Report of the Taxi Regulation Review Group was published on foot a wide ranging review carried out in line with a Government decision of June 2011. The Review Group, which was convened and chaired by the then Minister for Public and Commuter Transport, Alan Kelly T.D., included dispatch operators, drivers, vehicle owners and consumers as well as Government Departments and regulatory and enforcement agencies. The aim of the review was to allow consumers to have confidence in the taxi system while also ensuring that legitimate and competent operators and drivers could be rewarded fairly by operating under a regulatory framework that is adequately enforced. This “Taxi Roof Sign Consultation” derives from the actions recommended within the Report.

Action 13 of the Report of the Taxi Regulation Review Group states:

To design, for consultation with the industry, a new taxi roof sign that is more compact, is subject to restricted availability from authorised suppliers, and can display a greater level of information for consumer and compliance improvements. Consideration will be given to the use of electronic displays as part of the roof sign and the future-proofing of the sign to link with future developments in the area of taxi technology.

This consultation on taxi roof signs is in response to the recommendation of the Taxi Regulation Review Report.

Roof Sign Design Considerations

A new roof sign design could range from a simple static informational roof sign through to an interactive electronic roof sign that displayed only data pulled from the live SPSV register held by the Authority via mobile communication links. This latter concept offers potential for a “real time, live location” features to benefit driver and passenger safety.

The design of any new roof sign for use on taxis in Ireland would need to consider the following:

  • Size and impact on vehicle fuel consumption;
  • Cost;
  • Information to be displayed on sign;
  • Visibility of sign information during day time and night time hours;
  • Use of technology including electronic displays;
  • Consistency of appearance and quality;
  • Durability;
  • Vehicle fixing; and
  • Supply arrangements and level of supply control.

In relation to impact on fuel usage of the vehicle, Appendix 1 provides information on fuel economy tests carried out on two vehicle models using the current roof sign design.

Examples of Taxi Roof Signs

 

Two styles of current roof sign in Ireland.

taxi-roof-sign-1 taxi-roof-sign-2

A common small UK roof sign.

uk-roof-sign

Generic standard UK roof sign design, approx. 450mm x 150mm x 150m

generic-uk-roof-sign

The large combined roofsign plus advertising light box on a New York yellow cab.

large-roof-sign-advertising-light-box-new-york

Roof rail mounted generic German style roof sign

rail-german-roof-sign

Programmable/variable message digital electronic taxi roof sign, (courtesy “Pointguard AB Sweden”)

programmable-roof-sign-1 programmable-roof-sign-2
programmable-roof-sign-3 programmable-roof-sign-4

Consultation on New Roof Sign

This consultation document invites your submission in relation to a possible new roof sign for taxis. In particular your views are sought on the following:

1. Do you consider that a new taxi roof sign is required?
2. If you do consider that a new taxi roof sign is required, please state any suggestions or proposals that you wish to have considered.

Submissions, clearly marked “Taxi Roof Sign Consultation”, must be received by the Authority by 5pm, Friday 25 September 2015 either by email or post to the address details below:

Post: Taxi Roof Signs, National Transport Authority, Dún Scéine, Iveagh Court, Harcourt Lane, Dublin 2.
Email: taxiroofsign@nationaltransport.ie

 

Más mian leat páirt a glacadh sa leagan Gaeilge den Chomhairliúchán, déan cliceáil: An Comhairliúchán um Chomharthaí Dín Tacsaí 2015

 

Appendix 1: 2006 Roof Sign Fuel Economy Tests

(Extract from Commission for Taxi Regulation Vehicle Standards Report)

Roof Sign Wind Tunnel Test Summary Results

Two cars were tested in a full size wind tunnel facility to assess the effects of the Irish type roof sign on overall vehicle aerodynamics.

The two cars were the popular taxi model Toyota Avensis saloon, 2006 specification and the hybrid Toyota Prius 2006 specification. Both were tested at 32km/h (20mph) and 97 km/h (60mph) wind speed to assess the effects at town and country road speeds. Both cars were tested empty of passengers but in running condition.

Tests were undertaken for five different configurations:

Configuration 1: Base vehicle, no sign
Configuration 2: As per configuration 1 plus roof sign at frontmost position
Configuration 3: As per configuration 1 plus roof sign at midroof position
Configuration 4: As per configuration 1 plus roof sign at rearmost position
Configuration 5: As per configuration 1 plus roof sign longitudinally orientated

Summary of the results for both models

Estimated power from measured drag and frontal area for 97 km/h (60mph) road speed:

Specification

Prius (kW)

Avensis (kW)

Configuration 1 7.9 8.5
Configuration 2 11.7 12.0
Configuration 3 11.7 12.5
Configuration 4 11.0 12.3
Configuration 5 8.1 8.8

 

This consultation is now closed.

 

Report on 2015 Public Consultation on Taxi Roof Signs